3.6 Donor conception is different

Part 16 of
24
From this chapter you will learn:
  • How openness about donor origins benefits children’s identity and family relationships
  •  The role of grief, adjustment, and counselling in decision-making
  •  How laws, culture, and DNA testing have reshaped donor anonymity
  •  Specific emotional and practical considerations for heterosexual couples, single parents, and same-sex couples
  •  The importance of preparing parents for the long-term implications of donor conception

Introduction

This section puts the case that donor conception is significantly different from fertility procedures undertaken with a couple or the individual’s own gametes. In many ways it is not ‘fertility’ treatment at all but a different route to parenthood and needs to be acknowledged as such.
People considering donor conception will need to engage with issues that others undergoing treatment with their own eggs or sperm do not have to consider. First and foremost is the perspective and long-term well-being of the child they hope to create. The upshot of this is the responsibility to share with the child the fact that he/she was donor-conceived and, if possible, to have some information available about the donor(s). Sharing information about donor conception with significant others in the child’s life is also an important consideration.

Background

In the past, secrecy about donor conception, from the child and others, was considered to be in the best interests of all parties. It was believed to protect the infertile parent from societal censure, the doctors concerned from professional disapproval, and the child from bewilderment and mockery. There was also a lack of clarity around the legal status of the parent and donor.
But times and opinions have now changed. Parents are more willing to share information about their use of donated gametes. Many now see it as ethically wrong to conceal the truth from their children. Clinics advertise rather than hide their donor conception services.
Donor-conceived adults – those who have been told about or who have discovered their beginnings – are asserting their rights not only to be told but also to find out about their genetic heritage. States and private organisations now keep registers of donor- conceived individuals and donors. Direct-to-consumer DNA testing now provides previously unforeseen opportunities. Adult individuals may discover that a parent or parents is/are not as they expected. They may also be able to connect with genetic relatives. The USA is leading the way in connecting groups of half-siblings and sometimes their donor as well, but this is also happening in Europe. Clinics need to recognise that anonymous donation cannot be guaranteed and that secrecy is not a wise strategy for parents.
These are all reasons why donor conception is different to creating life with the parents’ own gametes and why potential parents need to think about their children’s future before rather than after treatment.
The role of clinics and support organisations is important in helping potential parents to understand from the outset that donor conception is a different way of forming a family and, not just a modified IVF treatment cycle. Donor conception is not right for everyone.

The move from secrecy to openness

The DC Network refers to ‘openness’ rather than ‘disclosure’ about donor conception because openness indicates a state of mind over time and disclosure implies a one-off sharing of the information. A willingness to be open with other family members and with the child may be a good indicator that would-be parents have moved on from feelings of their own loss and sadness and are focusing on the child-to-be.
Good support from their clinic staff and counsellor is important in helping to bring about this change in mind-set. But for many would-be parents, contact with other families through a support organisation such as the DC Network can be a major confidence booster. Parents who are at ease with the decisions they have made and are comfortable talking about donor conception are most likely to raise children who are confident in their own identity.

Loss

When an individual or couple need help to conceive a child, loss is an inevitable part of the process: loss of hopes and dreams of producing a child with a partner through an act of love, loss of control as cycles and medical processes seem to dominate every facet of life and the loss of spontaneous connection. Donor conception adds another layer of loss for all types of family.

Everyone experiences the loss of a full genetic link and the need to acknowledge the fact that another man or woman, known or unknown, is helping to produce the child they will raise. Many single women and men may regret not having a partner to have a child with; lesbian and gay couples would have liked to create a new life with their partner; and heterosexual couples, assuming that they would be able to conceive without help, grieve their inability to do so and the loss of their beloved partner’s contribution to creating the child they so hoped to have together.

Donor conception offers the hope of a child but, unless losses are acknowledged and grieved for initially, it is hard, particularly for heterosexual couples, to move to a place where hope is the dominant emotion. Clinic staff who understand this can support couples and individuals in the grieving process by not pressing them to make decisions about donor conception too quickly. The passage of time is not only hugely valuable for healing wounds created by loss, but it is also likely to result in better decision-making when the time is right.

Loss is not just felt by those seeking treatment. Staff who have invested professional and emotional energy to help those who have not achieved a pregnancy despite numerous attempts may feel loss or even a sense of failure. Because of the emphasis on own-gamete conception, it can sometimes be quite difficult for staff to close the door on this option and suggest donor conception instead. To overcome feelings of inadequacy, guilt or loss per se, the implications of this move may be minimised. It can be helpful for staff to be able to recognise their own feelings and get support if necessary. This will help them to better focus on supporting the person or persons concerned in grieving their loss and considering gamete donation. Counselling can be valuable for everyone involved.

Who is the donor?

Attitudes to donors have changed over time. In the past, sperm donors were considered simply as providers of a means to an end. Their contribution was gratefully received by clinics and recipients alike, but no-one wanted to know more about them as people.

More recently, parental attitudes to children have begun to change. A minority of parents started to reject the advice they had received. Secrecy, they thought, was not a sound basis for strong family relationships. It was ethically wrong to conceal the truth from children about important facts that concerned them.

In the UK, a social movement to encourage parents to tell their children about their conception grew. At the same time, the voices of donor-conceived adults who had discovered their origins were starting to be heard. They asserted a right to know who their biological fathers were. Simply telling children they were donor-conceived was not enough. Some countries, including the UK, provided additional non-identifying information and made this available to potential parents. The donor as a recognisable individual began to emerge, thus challenging the idea of anonymity.

Starting with Sweden in 1985, some countries, including the UK in 2004, passed laws to allow identifying information about donors (and sometimes half siblings) to be accessible to donor-conceived people at the age of 18. Donors were also given rights to limited information about the outcome of their donations. Known donation from a family member or friend became more widely considered and donor conceived adults gave their seal of approval.

Direct-to-consumer DNA testing

More recently, the landscape has completely changed once again with direct-to-consumer DNA testing becoming widely available, inexpensive and popular. As a result, connections are being made, both intentionally and unintentionally, between donor-conceived people and their donors, and between donor-conceived half-siblings. Because of the potential for future connection, the donor needs to be acknowledged from the outset as a real person who could enter the life of a donor-conceived person at some point.

It is a modern reality that must be understood by donors, parents and potential parents as well as by donor conception and clinical professionals.

Specific implications for each family type

Heterosexual couples: Moving from own-gamete treatment to considering using a donor or donors is a major transition for most couples. As with all transitions feelings can be up and down, changing daily and hourly. A complication can be if each partner feels differently about donor conception. If well supported and un-pressured about decision-making, couples may move from feeling devastated to accepting the use of gametes from another person to help create the situation they desire – parenthood. Others may come to the decision that it is not right for them, and possibly their culture or community, to bring a child created in this way into their world. Both decisions should be considered appropriately good outcomes. Counselling, ideally more than one session, can be very beneficial in helping would-be parents to understand the responsibilities of becoming a parent by donor conception and to decide whether or not they feel they can take these on.

Single women and men: Becoming a parent without a current partner is a life-changing decision for most women and men contemplating donor conception (plus surrogacy for men). As well as the emotional impact, there are the practical considerations of parenting alone to take into account. Single women with fertility issues find that the move from using their own eggs to accepting double or embryo donation can be a transition similar to that faced by heterosexual couples and often felt as an additional loss. Reassessment of her situation with the support of a counsellor can be helpful as a woman not only needs to adjust to her own loss but also to the potential losses felt by her child who will be raised without a second parent or a genetic link to their mother.

Solo parenthood for men is a newer phenomenon but shares some features with single women. With the support of a clinic team and counselling services, men wishing to become single parents can be helped to understand their responsibilities and the challenges they may face in making the best decisions for their child.

Same-sex couples: For many same-sex couples, the dominant emotion on contemplating donor conception is delight that there is now a way for them to have a genetically connected family.

Female couples may face difficult questions about which partner should carry a child or attempt a pregnancy first. One woman may donate an egg to her partner so that she might experience pregnancy and birth whilst the genetic connection would be with the donating partner. Fertility difficulties may also be encountered, leading to the need for double embryo donation and the associated feelings of loss of genetic connection.

For male couples, which partner should provide the sperm to create an embryo with an egg from the surrogate mother or egg donor, is often a tricky question. Some male couples seek to create embryos with sperm from each partner and then have one from each man transferred to the uterus of a surrogate. The hoped-for result is twins where no-one should know the genetic link to each man.

In the UK, the right of a child to know their genetic parentage has been law since 2005 and British men who have twins created in this latter way cannot gain full legal parentage until their children have undertaken DNA tests to establish genetic links to each partner. The genetic relationship may feel irrelevant to the parents but is important information for the children.

Same-sex couples must inevitably start to share information about donor conception with their children and others before their offspring encounter children from heterosexual families in nursery onwards. Gay men are probably more likely to talk about their surrogate (and hopefully have an on-going relationship with her) but, if a separate egg donor was used, she may not be mentioned and the child and others may come to believe that the surrogate is the genetic as well as the birth mother.

Counselling and good preparation for donor-conception parenthood by the clinic or a support organisation like DC Network, can be helpful to all potential parents in addressing the issues that are specific to them, as well as those they share with other family types.

Using donor conception following unassisted conception or IVF with own gametes

Some families may find themselves seeking donor conception whilst already being a parent to a child conceived without donor assistance. Exactly the same principles regarding loss, adjustment over time and openness with all children and significant others apply. It is important for these parents to explore how they feel about having children with different origins and how this may impact each child and the whole family. DCN has a booklet that can help potential parents address the many questions they may have.

Using a different donor for second or subsequent children

Where there are no frozen embryos from a previous cycle of donor IVF or IVF was not used for a previous donor pregnancy, it is sometimes not possible for the same donor to be used for a second or subsequent child. Parents seeking full biological siblings often find this situation distressing. Counselling is likely to be helpful for parents, supporting them in thinking through what is most important to them and what might or might not be important for the siblings. All the same principles outlined in this section apply.

Cross-border differences

As previously mentioned in this chapter, many people seek donor conception procedures in countries other than where they are citizens. This is due to a number of reasons but primarily speed of treatment, availability of donors, money and the ability to have a procedure that is not allowed in their own country.

For example, egg donation is prohibited in a number of European countries. This means that those people for whom egg donation is the only way they might be able to conceive, must either forgo their dreams or travel abroad. If they conceive and return to their own country for the pregnancy and birth of the child, they are confronted with both legislative and cultural differences and have to decide whether or not to reveal their method of conception. If they do not reveal it, then inappropriate testing may be proposed during pregnancy and openness with the child will be compromised.

Women from the UK sometimes go elsewhere in Europe for egg donation because treatments are cheaper there. In most of these countries, the donors remain anonymous and little information is given. On returning to the UK, parents discover the prevailing culture of openness and may feel bad about having little information to share with their children and no way, other than a DNA test, for children to find genetic relatives.

Parents with anonymous donors sometimes console themselves about the lack of information by assuming that DNA testing will solve this issue in the future. This is, however, not guaranteed and even if the donor is identified they may reject contact because they did not agree to their identity being known. In addition, there may be language and cultural difficulties.

It is vital that these issues are raised with potential parents, ideally by counsellors, but they should also be embedded in the culture of the clinic where patients begin and end their treatment.

Donor conception tomorrow?

We have witnessed the wind of change in social attitudes, legal rights and scientific progress over the last generation. What felt unthinkable 30 years ago is happening today, and what feels unthinkable today will likely be happening 10 or 20 years from now. Donor-conceived children born today will see changes during their lifetime that we cannot accurately predict.

While the desire to create families and have children – regarded as a “human universal” – is unlikely to change, the ways of meeting the needs of those for whom the route to parenthood is not straightforward will inevitably alter. It is impossible to predict the future norm. Will intending parents and gamete donors expect to meet each other ahead of any medical procedures, in much the same way that intending parents and surrogates do now? Will the role of clinics continue to involve matching donors and recipients or will they only carry out the medical treatment? Will central registers of donors and treatment cycles still be maintained? Will the business of counsellors expand or contract? What will be the implications for birth certification and legal responsibility? Or will all of these questions be bizarrely outdated 20 years from now?

Recommendations

  • Recognise that donor conception is different
  • The first responsibility of those who manage fertility clinics is to make sure that their clinic culture acknowledges that donor conception is different. Appropriate recruitment, staff training and support should all reflect this.
  • All those contemplating donor conception should be prepared for a different kind of parenthood. Support organisations and counsellors have a major role to play here.
  • All clinic staff need to be willing to engage with the particular issues that would-be donor-conception parents face.
  • Clinics must acknowledge that time to grieve, consider and move to the right decision for individual/couple and child, is vital,
  • Donors and prospective parents need to be aware of the implications of DNA testing with respect to openness and anonymity. It should also be noted that DNA testing is not a panacea for anonymity.
  • The mind-set and feelings of parents and donor-conceived children and adults can change over time. Parents need support to understand that the choices they make before treatment could have implications in the future.

Disclaimer:
This article is for general information only. It is not a substitute for medical advice. If you have specific fertility concerns, please speak with a healthcare professional or fertility specialist. It was developed to support patient understanding of current fertility research and guidance. For personalised advice, please consult your healthcare provider.