4.2 Helping patients make good, safe choices

Part 19 of
24
From this chapter you will learn:
  • Key barriers to safe decision-making in virtual fertility care, such as low health literacy, reduced non-verbal cues, and online misinformation
  •  How to ensure informed consent in ART, including essential topics and cross-border issues
  •  Best practices for presenting complex treatment information clearly and sensitively
  •  How patient-centred care and good telehealth etiquette improve trust, outcomes, and reduce drop-out rates

Introduction

Prior to 2020, the fertility industry had been slow to embrace telehealth and other technologies. Unlike our more agile colleagues, assisted reproductive technology (ART) practitioners had favoured a more traditional approach, largely due to regulation and user and provider opposition (1). However, the COVID-19 pandemic changed this, requiring fertility clinics to rapidly implement virtual consultation and communication services, with delivery of patient care transformed forever. This will continue to evolve with the development of artificial intelligence (AI) and Web 3.0. This section of the guide will address potential barriers to care, in our new virtual world, and make recommendations to fertility clinics on how to ensure that they continue to help patients make good, safe choices.

Potential barriers to care

Health Literacy

Health literacy is the capacity in which a patient is able to search for, understand and use various information sources and services in order to make appropriate treatment decisions for themselves. Health literacy varies from person to person. It depends on the level of education, age, language, culture and background (2). Lower levels of health literacy are associated with increased misunderstanding of information and decreased patient involvement in shared decision-making. Clinic staff should be aware that barriers to virtual communication, such as reduced implicit feedback, levels of digital literacy (in both patients and staff) and exclusion (not all patients are comfortable with a digital set up or have the correct equipment available to them) may reduce health literacy.

Virtual communication

As previously mentioned, communication is at the core of healthcare. Misunderstanding health information leads to errors, miscommunication and poor decision-making. Accurate information gathering enables correct diagnosis, treatment, counselling and relationship building with patients. Good communication improves the patient’s emotional and physical wellbeing, increases health literacy and improves their overall experience. This then reduces treatment drop-out and the potential for complaints and litigation. However, there are a number of barriers to communication that may disrupt this process, particularly when relying solely on virtual communication. Studies have shown that 65% of communication is non-verbal. Physical appearance, eye contact, body language, tone of voice, air pressure, smell, ambient sound and feelings of empathy, all affect clarity and interpretation (3). These non-verbal clues are reduced or eliminated in virtual communication, which may cause disconnection and misunderstanding (4).

Impaired informed consent and shared decision-making

We previously mentioned the importance of consent forms and what they should include, but we would like to stress the point that informed consent can only be given by someone who is competent (has the capacity to understand the proposed action), has been given adequate information (understands the risks, benefits, consequences and possible alternatives) and who willingly volunteers their consent (without duress) (5). There are multiple factors that may affect a fertility patient’s medical decision-making ability:

  • Not all clinics give adequate information to patients prior to treatment, which causes them to turn to social media and/or the Internet to fill in the gaps. This form of information is often contradictory, unreliable, incomplete and non-patient specific. This then reduces the patient’s ability to provide informed consent.
  • Patients are increasingly sharing their infertility journey on social media. In 2019, there were 3,393,636 Instagram posts sharing fertility-related information, the majority of which were authored by patients (6). Research indicates that patient’s choices are influenced by anecdotal stories of success and media misinformation, which may ultimately have a negative impact upon a patient’s ability to make an informed treatment choice (7).
  • Fertility patients may be embarrassed to report that they do not fully understand their treatment plan or have made an error with the administration of medication, for example. This leads clinic staff to overestimate how much information has been understood (8).
  • Decision-making about medical treatment can be a stressful and difficult process, particularly when undergoing fertility treatment (9).

Recommendations to assist patients in making good, safe choices

Personalised care and shared decision-making

Good clinical practice involves high-quality, patient-centred, personalised, evidence-based care, in which patients are able to make autonomous, informed decisions (10). Shared decision-making and informed consent should be an integral part of the ART protocol, but what is the best way to achieve this? It is a well-known fact that patients forget 40-80% of verbal information immediately and only half of what they do remember is correct (11). Therefore, medical personnel should provide transparent, honest information, presented in a format that can be easily understood and remembered. This ensures realistic expectations in the patient’s specific situation, thereby reducing the burden of being a fertility patient, treatment drop-outs and any fear of regret in the future (12).

Informed consent

The consent to undergo ART treatment is unique in that it is intended to create children. To ensure that patients are able to provide informed consent, clinics should supply information regarding:

  • benefits and risks of treatment options and alternatives;
  • individualised treatment success rates;
  • the procurement, use, storage and future use of eggs, sperm and embryos;
  • independent psychological and implication counselling;
  • the welfare of the child/children;
  • cost schedule;
  • clinic complaints procedure;
  • withdrawal or change to consent;
  • legal parenthood.

Specific patient groups, such as patients requesting cross-border reproductive care for gamete/embryo donation (both donors and recipients) should be provided with the following additional information:

  • Regulations governing the recruitment, payment and number of families or offspring created from egg, sperm and embryo donation varies from country to country;
  • With the increasing use of direct-to-consumer genetic testing and prenatal testing, patients who choose donor conception and the donors per se, should be informed that donor anonymity may no longer be guaranteed (13).

Information format

Fertility treatment is complex. It involves multiple processes that rely on highly motivated patients who are able to understand and adhere to instructions such as medication management. Studies have shown that despite attending a briefing session:

  • 35.7% of patients were anxious about self-injecting;
  • 38% were confused about the prescribed units of gonadotropin;
  • almost half either made or speculated that they had made an error in taking their medication;
  • 29% admitted not reporting this error to their clinic (14) (15).

Information provided prior to consent should pertain to both the physical and psychological aspects of treatment. It should be delivered in a culturally appropriate manner (16), which is sensitive to cross-cultural care, taking into account the health literacy of the individual patient (Table 1). Patients must be given the opportunity to fully absorb the information provided, before treatment commences, and then be encouraged to ask questions or clarify further points. This should be in a separate face-to-face video call, which allows for collaborative communication.

Telehealth and webside manner

Patients have embraced the benefits of telehealth, such as reduced travel time and cost, increased flexibility and availability. However, there are some practical issues which should be taken into account which improve both the patient’s experience, and protect both the patient and the clinic (Table 2.)

Implementing patient-centred infertility care

Patient-centred care is one of the six dimensions of quality of care comprising 1) safety, 2) effectiveness, 3) patient-centeredness, 4) timeliness, 5) equity and 6) efficiency. Many patients choose to stop ART treatment despite having a good predicted success rate and being able to afford the costs incurred. This is called patient drop-out. Most cite the impact of the psychological burden of infertility, but others refer to a lack of patient-centred care behind their decision. By implementing a patient-centred approach, clinics can improve their overall performance and reduce patient drop-out (17) (Table 3).

Conclusions

Both patients and clinics have welcomed the advantages of virtual healthcare. However, clinics should be aware that, in adopting these new methods of interaction, they must continue to encourage patients to be in control of their treatment decisions. Ensure that informed consent is obtained, reduce stress and lessen the patient workload. This will improve the overall experience and protect both the patient and the clinic.

Resources

  1. Where will telemedicine go from here? Rotker, K., Velez, D., Fertility and Sterility® Vol. 114, No. 6, December 2020
  2. Building the case for Health Literacy. Alper et al., 2018. Available at: https://www.nap.edu/catalog/25068/ building-the-case-for-health-literacy-proceedings-of-a-workshop. Accessed 15/06/21
  3. Nonverbal Communication (eBook). Burgoon et al., Boston: Allyn & Bacon, 2010
  4. Can You Hear Me? How to Connect with People in a Virtual World. Morgan N., Harvard Business Press, 2018
  5. Vulnerability and the Consenting Subject: Reimagining Informed Consent in Embryo Donation. Hewer, R., Feminist Legal Studies (2019) 27: 287–310
  6. Fertility education: what’s trending on Instagram. Peyser et al., Fertility Research and Practice 2021. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1186/s40738-021- 00095-6
  7. The impact of anecdotal information on medical decision-making. Jaramillo et al., 2019. Available at: https://cogsci.mindmodeling.org/2019/ papers/0100/0100.pdf
  8. Promoting patient comprehension of relevant health information Kreps, G.L., Isr J Health Policy Res 7, 56 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13584-018-0250-z
  9. Tackling burden in ART: an integrated approach for medical staff. Boivin et al., Human Reproduction, Vol.27, No.4 pp. 941–950, 2012
  10. Good Clinical Treatment in Assisted Reproduction – An ESHRE position paper. June 2008.
  11. Patients’ memory for medical information. Kessels, R.P.C., 2003. Available at: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm. nih.gov/12724430/.
  12. ‘Your hopes can run away with your realistic expectations’: a qualitative study of women and men’s decision-making when undergoing multiple cycles of IVF. Copp et al., Human Reproduction Open, Vol.00, No.0, pp. 1–8, 2020
  13. The end of donor anonymity: how genetic testing is likely to drive anonymous gamete donation out of business. Harper et al., Human Reproduction, Vol. 31, No.6 pp. 1135 –1140, 2016
  14. Understanding the burden of ovarian stimulation: fertility expert and patient perceptions. Huisman et al., Reproductive BioMedicine Online, Vol . 19, Supplement 2, 2009
  15. Patient perceptions and understanding of treatment instructions for ovarian stimulation during infertility treatment. Barrière et al., Reproductive BioMedicine & Society Online 2019 Available at: https://doi. org/10.1016/j.rbms.2019.08.003.
  16. Cultural competence in fertility care for lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer people: a systematic review of patient and provider perspectives. Kirubarajan et al., Fertility & Sterility 2021. Available at: https://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.fertnstert.2020.12.002
  17. How organisations contribute to improving the quality of healthcare. Fulop, N., Ramsey, A. BMJ 2019; 365: l1773.
  18. Patient-centered infertility care: a qualitative study to listen to the patient’s voice. Dancet et al. Human Reproduction, 2011. Available at: http://dx.doi. org/10.1093/humrep/der022

Disclaimer:
This article is for general information only. It is not a substitute for medical advice. If you have specific fertility concerns, please speak with a healthcare professional or fertility specialist. It was developed to support patient understanding of current fertility research and guidance. For personalised advice, please consult your healthcare provider.